PITTSFIELD, Mass. — A man who once attempted to attack an elderly woman is now poised for a new chapter following decades of struggles, including repeated legal battles and ongoing substance abuse issues. David Sibinich, 65, has been granted another chance by the Massachusetts Parole Board, which noted his lack of violent behavior since his initial offense.
Sibinich’s legal troubles date back to 1980 when, at the age of 22, he was apprehended following a violent encounter with 80-year-old Esther Berenholc. During the incident, Berenholc was found bound and severely injured in her home. According to authorities, she reported that Sibinich had attempted to smother her with a pillow and subsequently tied her up. Further disturbing evidence included signs of struggle and a diamond ring belonging to Berenholc found on Sibinich.
Though the elderly victim passed away from natural causes nearly two months after the assault, Sibinich faced significant legal repercussions. In 1982, he was convicted of multiple serious charges, including armed robbery and assault with intent to murder, resulting in a life sentence with the potential for parole. His initial attempt at parole in 1996 was unsuccessful, and subsequent hearings extended over the years.
After multiple denials, Sibinich was finally released on parole in 2007 but found himself back in custody due to a violation five years later. Since then, he faced additional challenges, with a return to prison in 2024 for another violation. However, during a recent review hearing on August 6, 2025, the parole board found that Sibinich had not engaged in any violent conduct since his conviction.
Despite his struggles with substance use, the board recognized his efforts towards rehabilitation. In their assessment, they highlighted the importance of Sibinich investing in his sobriety, pointing out that he acknowledged the need for support in this area. Berkshire County Assistant District Attorney Joseph Pieropan opposed the idea of granting Sibinich parole, citing concerns about public safety. Nonetheless, the board emphasized that Sibinich’s re-entry plan adequately addressed his specific needs.
On January 21, 2026, the parole board made a unanimous decision in favor of granting Sibinich parole. He is set to enter a Long-Term Residential Program, such as Soldier On, pending approval from the district attorney’s office. This decision marks a pivotal moment in Sibinich’s life as he seeks to rebuild his path forward, highlighting the ongoing complexities of reintegrating individuals with troubled pasts into society.