COLUMBIA, SC – A man accused of killing his neighbor’s nephew in a dispute over a lottery ticket will remain in jail after a judge denied bail on Thursday. The incident has left the community in shock, as the alleged shooter, Paul Williams, was known to be a friendly neighbor.
The victim, 67-year-old Matthew Fleming, was shot while working in his aunt’s backyard on Wednesday night. His aunt, Georgia Shanima Montgomery, is now left to care for his beloved dog, Rocky. She described her nephew as a kind-hearted man who always tried to avoid conflict.
Montgomery recounted that Fleming had been helping her with yard work before the tragedy occurred. Earlier in the day, Williams had assisted Fleming, and everything seemed amicable. However, Williams’ demeanor changed after returning from a trip to the store with Fleming.
Upon their return, Williams began quoting scriptures loudly and accused a neighbor of stealing money from him. Montgomery asked him to calm down, but the situation escalated. Fleming called out to his aunt, urging her to check on their neighbor, and moments later, a gunshot rang out.
According to a report from the Richland County Sheriff’s Department, deputies arrived at Williams’ home following his call about a stolen lottery ticket. As they approached, they heard a gunshot and saw Williams holding a firearm. He reportedly claimed that Fleming was the one who had been stealing his lottery tickets.
Fleming was rushed to the hospital, where he was pronounced dead. He leaves behind two daughters and several grandchildren. His dog, Rocky, is set to be taken in by one of his daughters.
Williams, 70, now faces a bond hearing in general sessions court. The community is grappling with the sudden violence, particularly given Williams’ previously good reputation as a neighbor. The incident serves as a stark reminder of how quickly situations can escalate into tragedy.
Montgomery expressed her heartbreak over losing her nephew, emphasizing how he always sought to avoid violence. The family now mourns the loss of a man who was not only a devoted family member but also a peace-loving individual.
The case continues to develop as the community comes to terms with the shocking events. As more details emerge, residents hope for justice and healing in the wake of this senseless act.