Tempe, Arizona — A violent group attack in the vicinity of Arizona State University (ASU) has left one victim hospitalized, prompting an ongoing investigation by the ASU police department.
The incident unfolded on September 28, starting in a dormitory room at Hassayampa Academic Village, where the victim and a friend were socializing. Tensions escalated when a group of males, unfamiliar to the victim, entered the space. An initial confrontation began when one individual allegedly shouldered the victim, leading to a brief verbal exchange before the group exited the dorm.
As the victim left the dorm later, surveillance footage captured a group of five to six males who noticed him and crossed the street to confront him. The situation quickly escalated when one assailant threw the first punch. As the victim attempted to defend himself, others joined in, forcing him to the ground.
Video evidence shows multiple attackers surrounding the victim, taking turns to strike him with punches and kicks, even holding him down during the assault. The violence continued until a bystander intervened, halting the aggressive encounter.
The victim suffered serious injuries, including a broken nose and a head injury, resulting in his admission to the hospital’s intensive care unit. He also sustained bruises to his abdomen and face.
Authorities have arrested four individuals in connection with the assault: one juvenile, Jayden Malik Smith, 19, Donnell Young, and Justin Michael Otis, both 18 years old. Police confirmed that none of the suspects are ASU students. They are all facing charges related to aggravated assault.
During a preliminary court hearing, the prosecutor announced intentions to pursue additional charges under a new law known as Preston’s Law, which addresses group attacks. This legislation was established in memory of Preston Lord, who was killed in a similar incident two years ago. Although the initial police paperwork did not include these charges, a prosecutor explained that updates to the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office booking system have yet to reflect the law.
Further complicating the case, it has come to light that one of the suspects, Justin Otis, is the son of a former Maricopa County judge now employed by the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office. Due to this potential conflict of interest, the case has been reassigned to the Coconino County Attorney’s Office.
The adult suspects were issued $10,000 secured appearance bonds. ASU police reiterated that their investigation remains open and continues to gather evidence related to the case.