Is Real Estate Still the Golden Goose of Retirement?

The perception of real estate as a “golden goose” for retirement is deeply entrenched in our financial culture. It’s an asset class that provides a physical structure and has the potential for significant monetary gains and income. But as we navigate through fluctuating markets, technology shifts, and evolving investment landscapes, one question remains: Is real estate still the golden goose of retirement?

Historical Returns

Historically, real estate has been a stalwart of consistent returns. Private real estate investments have had an average annual return of 9% from 1990 to 2020, according to NCREIF ( National Council of Real Estate Investment Fiduciaries). Comparatively, the S&P 500 has had an average annual return of about 10% during the same period. While these numbers are neck and neck, real estate offers a critical advantage—lower volatility. For risk-averse investors, this provides a compelling reason to include real estate in a diversified retirement portfolio.

Tax Benefits

The tax advantages of real estate investment cannot be overstated. Tax policies like the 1031 exchange allow investors to defer capital gains taxes, while depreciation rules enable them to offset income. This can provide a significant financial cushion for retirees looking to optimize their after-tax returns.


A well-known investment mantra is “Don’t put all your eggs in one basket,” real estate provides an excellent diversification opportunity. There is a generally low correlation between real estate and stock markets. This means that your real estate investments may remain stable or even appreciate when the stock market is down. The 2008 financial crisis was an outlier and not representative of typical market behavior.

Income Generation

Real estate can be a valuable retirement asset, as it has the potential to generate consistent income through rental properties. A recent report from Zillow states that as of September 2021, the median rent in the United States was $1,650. Owning multiple properties in strong rental markets can provide a steady income stream during retirement, potentially outpacing the fixed income generated by bonds or annuities.

The Flipside: Barriers and Risks

Despite these advantages, real estate investment isn’t without its drawbacks. It requires significant upfront capital, ongoing maintenance, and the ability to manage or afford property management services. Additionally, the real estate market isn’t uniformly buoyant across all regions or types of property. While commercial properties may offer stability, residential real estate can be subject to market fluctuations, zoning laws, and other variables that adversely affect property values and rental income.

Moreover, the rise of remote work has changed the dynamics of both residential and commercial real estate markets. With more people working from home, demand for commercial office space has decreased in some areas, and residential markets in traditionally overlooked regions are booming. Investors must adapt to these new trends to ensure their real estate assets continue to perform well.

Real estate continues to offer solid long-term returns, tax benefits, diversification, and income generation. However, it requires significant capital, management skills, and the ability to adapt to market trends. For those who can navigate these complexities, real estate remains an attractive component of a diversified retirement strategy. However, performing thorough due diligence and possibly consulting a financial advisor to tailor your real estate investments to your individual retirement goals and risk tolerance is essential.

For more retirement news: